Independent assessment of 10 consumer security solutions against 1,572 real-world Android malware samples.
Android is a mobile operating system developed by Google, based on a modified version of the Linux kernel and other open-source software. It is the dominant OS for a wide array of devices including smartphones, tablets, televisions (Android TV), and automotive systems (Android Auto).
As of mid-2026, Android accounts for roughly 68–69% of worldwide mobile operating system usage, serving an estimated 3.9 billion users. Its reach is even greater in key growth markets: in countries such as India, Brazil, Indonesia, Vietnam, and Turkey, Android's share exceeds 85%. Google released Android 17 on June 16, 2026, yet adoption of any single release remains gradual — Android 16, the most widely used version, represented only about a quarter of Android traffic worldwide in June 2026 — so the installed base continues to be spread across many OS generations and patch levels. This scale and diversity keep the Android ecosystem a uniquely attractive target for cybercriminals.
Zscaler ThreatLabz's 2025 Mobile, IoT and OT Threat Report, built on more than 20 million mobile threat-related transactions, recorded a 67% year-over-year rise in Android malware transactions, driven largely by spyware and banking Trojans. India was the most targeted country, receiving about 26% of mobile malware traffic (and 38% more attacks than a year earlier), followed by the United States (15%) and Canada (14%). Adware overtook the Joker family as the leading mobile threat at 69% of cases, while Joker fell to 23% from 38%. The same report counted 239 malicious apps on Google Play with a combined 42 million downloads, and documented a backdoor that infected 1.6 million Android-based TV boxes, primarily in India and Brazil.
Zimperium's 2026 Mobile Banking Heist Report tracked 34 active mobile malware families targeting 1,243 financial brands across 90 countries. Two-thirds of these families now enable full device control and 45% support financial extortion, including ransomware. In Asia-Pacific and Japan alone, 24 families were found targeting 214 core banking and fintech apps across 19 countries, according to a follow-up zLabs analysis published in September 2026. Regional campaigns continue to evolve: in October 2026, ThreatFabric reported a new Android banking remote access trojan, Hirudo, that replaces installed banking apps with patched copies to bypass their built-in security checks — with replacements identified for eight Indonesian banking apps, and credential targeting spanning Indonesia, China, India, Mexico, Morocco and Thailand. In August 2026, ThreatFabric also described Manic, a new family that blends banking-fraud functions with spyware and device-control features, targeting government institutions, banking applications and cryptocurrency wallets.
Zimperium's 2026 Global Mobile Threat Report, released on July 29, 2026, concluded that artificial intelligence is increasing the speed, scale and sophistication of mobile attacks, from more convincing phishing to malware development. The report cited LAMEHUG, an APT28 campaign that used AI to generate polymorphic malware on each execution, and PromptLock, the first identified AI-powered ransomware. For defenders, this reinforces the value of behavioral and machine-learning-based detection over purely static signatures.
Google's 2025 ecosystem report shows both the scale of abuse and the effect of platform controls. Google prevented more than 1.75 million policy-violating apps from being published on Google Play and banned more than 80,000 developer accounts (down from 2.36 million apps and 158,000 accounts in 2024). Outside the store, Google Play Protect, which scans more than 350 billion apps daily, identified more than 27 million new malicious apps from non-Play sources in 2025, roughly double the 13 million found in 2024. Google's internal analysis found malware appears more than 90 times as often in apps installed from sideloaded sources as in apps from Google Play. Its enhanced fraud protection, which blocks risky sideloaded installs that request sensitive permissions, now covers more than 2.8 billion devices in 185 markets and blocked 266 million installation attempts involving 872,000 unique high-risk apps in 2025; in Malaysia it is being rolled out with the National Cyber Security Agency.
Google's Android developer verification program began with the Android Developer Verifier in system settings in April 2026, followed by limited-distribution accounts and an advanced sideloading flow worldwide in August 2026. The first enforcement phase took effect on September 30, 2026: in Brazil, Indonesia, Singapore and Thailand, apps installed on certified Android devices must now come from developers registered with Google. A broader global roll-out is planned from 2027, and Malaysia has announced that all apps on certified devices there must come from verified developers by 2027. Even so, dedicated security applications remain an important additional layer, particularly on older devices and in markets where apps are commonly obtained from multiple sources.
To protect users from this evolving threat landscape, dedicated Android security applications must be continuously evaluated against real-world threats. This test is designed to independently assess the efficiency of consumer security solutions for the Android OS.
Sources: Zscaler ThreatLabz, “2025 Mobile, IoT and OT Threat Report” and press release (Nov 2025); Zimperium zLabs, “2026 Mobile Banking Heist Report” (Mar 2026), “2026 Global Mobile Threat Report” (29 Jul 2026) and “Mobile Fraud in 2026” APJ analysis (1 Sep 2026); ThreatFabric Mobile Threat Intelligence, “Manic” (20 Aug 2026) and “Hirudo” (14 Oct 2026), as reported by The Hacker News; Google Security Blog, “Keeping Google Play & Android app ecosystem safe in 2025” (Feb 2026); Google Malaysia announcement on enhanced Play Protect; Infosecurity Magazine on Android developer verification; StatCounter Global Stats (mobile OS and Android version share, Jun 2026); Android 17 release information.
This section outlines the methodology used for the test conducted in October 2026. The test environment and procedures were designed to ensure objectivity and reproducibility.
| Vendor | Software | Version |
|---|---|---|
| AhnLab | AhnLab V3 Mobile Security | 3.14.0.2(Build 4313) |
| Avast | Avast Mobile Security | 26.18.0.260925870 |
| Avira | Avira Antivirus Security for Android | 7.33.0 build No. 260908328 |
| Dr.Web | Dr.Web Mobile Security Suite | 12.9.12(2) |
| ESET | ESET Mobile Security | v. 12.0.17.0-15 |
| F-Secure | F-Secure Mobile Security | 26.9.1240618 |
| Kaspersky | Kaspersky Premium for Android | 11.133.4.15938 |
| McAfee | McAfee Mobile Security | 10.10.0.537 |
| NortonLifeLock | Norton 360 (Norton Mobile Security) | 26.18.0.260925980 |
| Total Defense | Total Defense Mobile Security | 16.4.3 |
| Vendor | Total | Missed | Detected | Detection Rate | False Positives | Final Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avast | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| Avira | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| F-Secure | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| Kaspersky | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| McAfee | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| NortonLifeLock | 1572 | 0 | 1572 | 100.00% | 0 | 100.00 |
| Total Defense | 1572 | 2 | 1570 | 99.87% | 0 | 99.87 |
| ESET | 1572 | 7 | 1565 | 99.55% | 0 | 99.55 |
| Dr.Web | 1572 | 37 | 1535 | 97.65% | 0 | 97.65 |
| AhnLab | 1572 | 60 | 1512 | 96.18% | 0 | 96.18 |
For each security solution, a Final Score is calculated once the full test is performed:
Final Score = (Detected / Total) × 100 − 0.2 × FP
| Final Score | Monthly Award |
|---|---|
| 98.00 – 100.00 | ★★★★★ 5-star rating |
| 95.00 – 97.99 | ★★★★ 4-star rating |
| 90.00 – 94.99 | ★★★ 3-star rating |
8 of 10 tested consumer products achieved 5-star ratings. Avast, Avira, F-Secure, Kaspersky, McAfee and NortonLifeLock achieved a perfect score of 100.00 with zero false positives across 1,572 malware samples. Dr.Web and AhnLab received 4-star ratings.
Gold outline = Perfect Score (100.00) with zero false positives
Dr.Web: 4-star rating (Final Score 97.65); AhnLab: 4-star rating (Final Score 96.18)
This test was conducted in accordance with the requirements of the AMTSO Testing Protocol Standard v1.3 (https://www.amtso.org/standards/). AMTSO's compliance review of this test has not yet been completed; this chapter and the report version will be updated once AMTSO confirms the outcome.
Unless otherwise stated, Testing Ground Labs (hereinafter referred to as "TG Labs"), owns the copyright of this report. Without prior written consent of TG Labs, no other organization or individual shall have the right to alter the contents of this report and use it for commercial purposes by any means (including but not limited to transmission, dissemination, reproduction, excerpt, etc.).
Unless otherwise stated, TG Labs shall be the rightful owner of the trademarks and service marks used in the report. Any action of infringing upon the legal rights of TG Labs is prohibited. TG Labs shall have the right to pursue the legal liability of the infringer in accordance with the law.
Before using this report issued by Testing Ground Labs (hereinafter "TG Labs"), please read and understand the following terms and conditions (the "Disclaimer") carefully, including provisions that limit or exclude TG Labs' liability and that restrict the rights of users. Use of this report constitutes acceptance of, and agreement to, all terms and conditions set forth herein.
TG Labs reserves the right to interpret, amend, and update this Disclaimer at any time.